For a normal revolver I would say you could load DEX rounds per turn.  If you wanted to make it a bit more dramatic you could do a simple DEX check and load a round per level of success per round.  This could really be interesting if you were under pressure trying to reload before some Horror eats your face.  For the Peacemaker I think I would go with the second choice since it is so involved. 

It's not the Heat, it's the Humanity.
Unisystem Lord of the Rings